If you leave it for long enough you will develop very fruity, almost raisin like flavours - no vinegar smell ... I did mine with nearly colour cured but not quite finished leaf.
Mine had some moisture content locked in the centre when I tried it ... it's not easy to cut, but can be ... and you can get an incredibly fine cut by using a kitchen mandoline set to 0.5mm to shave it.
Would you say it's any different than plug?
It's not that different, but it uses different and more primative technology to apply the pressure. The biggest difference with the carrotte method is that the compression of the tobacco and therefore the way it ends up curing is much less even - the centre of the carrotte is much darker and more fermented than the tobacco at the edges, having been under the most pressure and with the most anerobic conditions (also retaining the most moisture) ... this leads to much more fermented perique-like notes coming from the centre of the slice while the outside is much more close to air cured tobacco. Essentially what you get in each coin is a little blend.
What I like about this method is that it can be done with not-quite colour cured leaf without that being detrimental to the end product. The compression of the leaf means it is taking up very little space while still curing and uses only cloth, rope and man-power to achieve this. In my mold prone climate it's great to be able to hang a 1lb carrotte in the space I would otherwise only get one pair of leaves in!
We discuss any variety of tobacco, as well as numerous approaches to growing, harvesting, curing, and finishing your crop. Our members will attempt to provide experience-based answers to your questions.