The Besuki comparison grow is more interesting than I expected. To recap, I am growing Besuki (which is an Indonesian wrapper/binder variety) from three different seed sources. One source is tabakanbau, a tobacco seed vendor in Germany. The other two sources are the communities of Kesilir and Ambulu, both in Indonesia, and both collected by Tutu.
I observed in an earlier post that the Besuki (tabakanbau) resembles a white-stem burley, whereas the other two have normal, green stalks and veins.
At this point in the season, the Besuki (tabakanbau) clearly produces larger leaves than the other two. Also, both the Besuki (Kesilir) and the Besuki (Ambulu) are beginning to blossom. The Besuki (tabakanbau) show no indication of blossoming yet.
Soon, I will begin priming the leaf. I think a final judgement will have to wait for the three Besuki variants to be smoked.
Priming vs Stalk-Harvesting Havana Types
The topped Vuelta Abajo plant in the above photo exhibits signs of maturity (thickening, increasing rugosity) in nearly all the leaves. Last year, I stalk-harvested Veulta Abajo, Criollo (Cuba) and Coroja (Cuba). Contrary to the image of the lovingly primed leaf being pampered all the way to the cigar, these varieties hung as entire stalks in the shed (some of them not coming out until today). I have to say that I have been impressed with the final kilned quality of this leaf. The Criollo and Coroja have both provided over 80% wrapper-grade leaves. They are delicious, sturdy enough for binder use, and burn beautifully. These two taste so good, that often, after using a double Criollo binder, for example, I just skip applying the wrapper.
There are two major considerations in deciding to stalk-harvest primo cigar leaf:
1. Does the variety mostly mature synchronously, or do most of the upper leaves remain thin and immature while the lower leaf starts to ripen?
2. Are you willing to handle the process of stalk cutting and housing the tobacco with the same care used in priming leaf?
If the answers to both are yes, then your method of harvesting and hanging just comes down to your own preference, as well as the suitability of your curing shed for hanging whole stalks.
It's worth remembering that topping a plant accelerates the maturation of the upper leaves.
Bob